← Back to stories

Disney's Live-Action Moana Remake Panned by Critics

entertainmentbusinessSignificance: 3/10

The Facts

Disney's live-action remake of its 2016 animated film Moana has received poor reviews from critics, landing a 39% score on Rotten Tomatoes. Dwayne Johnson reprises his role as the demigod Maui in the film, which was released less than a decade after the original animated hit. Critics have questioned the rationale behind remaking a relatively recent animated film.

How different outlets are framing this

BBC News and Fox News both report on the negative critical reception, but their framing differs significantly in tone and emphasis. The BBC's coverage centres on the critical verdict itself, using the word 'dismal' and focusing on the quality of the film as a standalone product. It contextualises the story around the decade gap since the original animation and Johnson's return to the role, keeping the narrative relatively contained to the film itself.

Fox News, by contrast, frames the story as part of a broader pattern of Disney failures, explicitly linking the Moana remake to the earlier box office disappointment of Snow White and invoking the language of financial disaster ('box office shipwreck'). This framing positions the story less as a film review and more as evidence of systemic problems at Disney, appealing to a readership already familiar with — and potentially invested in — a narrative of Disney's commercial and creative decline. The Fox News headline is notably more adversarial toward the studio, whereas the BBC's headline places the emphasis on critical opinion rather than corporate accountability.

Source Articles